View Source

h3. Proposal from

Antonio Marchesi, Spanish Alternate Delegate.


h3. Proposal title

Change of requirements for the validity of a championship.


h3. Existing text

*S10*


*4.3* VALIDITY OF A CHAMPIONSHIP

*4.3.3* The title of champion shall be awarded only if there have been at least 6 separate valid tasks in the class.

h3. New text

{panel}
*S10*

*4.3* VALIDITY OF A CHAMPIONSHIP

*4.3.3* The title of champion shall be awarded only if there have been at least 6 separate valid tasks in the class, {color:#ff0000}and at least one task of each type (navigation, economy, precision) has been valid{color}.
{panel}

h3. Reason

A feeling of panic arises when we talk about the validity of a championship, but with our current rules a championship with only 6 precision tasks would be valid, as long as there is no way to enforce the task proportions.

Strong limits could be imposed, like \+/-5% of the established percentage of each task type, but this proposal only tries to avoid nonsense championships.