Page Comparison - 01 - Normalization of point values (v.1 vs v.2) - CIMA Section 10 - FAI wiki

Access Keys:: Skip to content (Access Key - 0)

All CIMA spaces

This space

 - Normalization of point values
 
                                        
                                            
    
    
        
    
    
                    
    

 



    
    
    
    
    

 
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
























                       
    
     

                
                
                    
                    
                    
                        
                            
                                
                                Version 1 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:57.
                                

                            
                                                                                
                    
                    compared with
                    
                        
                            
                                

                                                                            Version 2 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:59.
                                    
                                

                                                            
                                                                                    
                                
                                                                        Changes from 2 to 3 >>
                                

                            
                                                    
                    
                    
                    
                

            
            
                Key

                This line was removed.
                This word was removed. This word was added.
                This line was added.
            
            

              
      Comment:
      

  


                            Changes (13)
                View page history

                                                    
    

            
            ...
h3. Proposal from 
 
Ryoya IGARISHI (JAP) 
 
h3. Proposal title 
 
01 - Normalization of point values for championship task types 
 
 
h3. Existing text 
 
*S10* 
 
*4.29 CHAMPIONSHIP TASKS* 
 
4.29.1 &nbsp;On each flying day a task shall be set chosen from A4, unless prevented by the weather. 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A precision task may be combined with a cross--country task or set separately as specified 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; at briefing. If possible, two tasks should be set on each day for each class. 
 
4.29.2 &nbsp;The tasks to be used shall be chosen from the Task Catalogue defined by the Director, 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; based on the Master Task Catalogue, S10 A4. 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Task Catalogue shall be approved by CIMA and precisely set out in the local regulations 
 

            &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;together with the method of scoring. 
 

            4.29.3 &nbsp;Tasks shall, as far as practicable, conform to the following guidelines in standard championships:\\ 

            \\ 

             
*For Microlight aircraft classes AL, WL WF and GL* 

            ...
 
A &nbsp;Tasks for flight planning, navigation, etc with no fuel limit: 65% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
B &nbsp;Tasks for fuel economy, speed, duration, etc with limited fuel: 20% of the total value of the tasks 
 

            &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; flown. 
 

            C &nbsp;Precision tasks: 15% of the total value of the tasks flown.\\ 

            \\ 

             
*For Paramotor aircraft classes PF and PL* 

            ...
 
A &nbsp;Navigation: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
B &nbsp;Economy: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
C &nbsp;Precision: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
h3. New text 
 
{panel} 

            (added after text above): 
 

            {color:#ff0000}4.29.4 Final scores for a paramotor championship (classes PF and PL) are calculated by normalizing the points according to the following ratios:{color} 

             
{color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Precision tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color} 

            ...
 
{color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Navigation tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Economy tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}&nbsp;{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}Therefore, the winner has a maximum score of 9000 points (if they are the winner in each of the three task types){color} 
{panel} 
 
h3. Reason 
 
The score of each task must be evaluated equally in the championship competition. 
 
Section 10 states that where practicable, the tasks should ideally be balanced by 33% to each type of task: 
 
Navigation tasks 33%. 
 

            Economy tasks 33% 
 

            Precision tasks 33%\\ 

            \\ 

             

            The points awarded at AOPC2017 were heavily weighted towards precision tasks.\\ 

            \\ 

             
At AOPC2017: 

            ...
 
Economy task T6 T9 T13 scored up to 90 points, 23% of total points value 
 
The navigation task has a T1 T9 scored of up to 60 points, 15.3% of total points value 
 
Precision Task T2 T3 T4 T5 T8 T10 T11 T12 scored up to 240 points, 61.5% of total points value 
 
Total score 390 points were distributed as follows: Economy tasks 23%, Navigation tasks 15.3%, and Precision tasks 61.5% 
 

            This ratio is clearly far outside of the CIMA S10 recommendation for task balance at classic competitions, and may have significantly disadvantaged pilots that have selected their equipment optimized for economy or navigation.&nbsp; 
 

            This proposal is made out of concern that a similar imbalance might occur 2018 World Paramotor Championships, which will be hosted on the same site by the same organization team, which would contravene CIMA S10 guidelines and the spirit of fair and balanced competition that is the objective of classic style competitions.\\ 

            \\ 

             

            I propose to solve this problem with this amendment to S10 to be approved by the CIMA Plenary. For example, if many precision tasks are flown at a classic championship, you will normalize the total of that score to a maximum of 3000 points, so do not affect the results of other Navigation or Economy tasks.\\ 

            \\ 

             
Japan delegate Ryoya Igarashi
-                                Version 1 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:57.
                                

                            
                                                                                
                    
                    compared with
                    
                        
                            
                                

                                                                            Version 2 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:59.
                                    
                                

                                                            
                                                                                    
                                
                                                                        Changes from 2 to 3 >>
+                Key

                This line was removed.
                This word was removed. This word was added.
                This line was added.
-                                Version 1 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:57.
+                                                                            Version 2 by Barney Townsend
 on 10 Aug, 2017 18:59.
                                    
                                

                                                            
                                                                                    
                                
                                                                        Changes from 2 to 3 >>
 ...
h3. Proposal from 
 
Ryoya IGARISHI (JAP) 
 
h3. Proposal title 
 
01 - Normalization of point values for championship task types 
 
 
h3. Existing text 
 
*S10* 
 
*4.29 CHAMPIONSHIP TASKS* 
 
4.29.1 &nbsp;On each flying day a task shall be set chosen from A4, unless prevented by the weather. 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A precision task may be combined with a cross--country task or set separately as specified 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; at briefing. If possible, two tasks should be set on each day for each class. 
 
4.29.2 &nbsp;The tasks to be used shall be chosen from the Task Catalogue defined by the Director, 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; based on the Master Task Catalogue, S10 A4. 
 
&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Task Catalogue shall be approved by CIMA and precisely set out in the local regulations
 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; &nbsp;together with the method of scoring.
 .29.3 &nbsp;Tasks shall, as far as practicable, conform to the following guidelines in standard championships:\\
+\\
 *For Microlight aircraft classes AL, WL WF and GL*
 ...
 
A &nbsp;Tasks for flight planning, navigation, etc with no fuel limit: 65% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
B &nbsp;Tasks for fuel economy, speed, duration, etc with limited fuel: 20% of the total value of the tasks
 &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; flown.
 C &nbsp;Precision tasks: 15% of the total value of the tasks flown.\\
+\\
 *For Paramotor aircraft classes PF and PL*
 ...
 
A &nbsp;Navigation: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
B &nbsp;Economy: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
C &nbsp;Precision: 33% of the total value of the tasks flown. 
 
h3. New text 
 
{panel}
 (added after text above):
 {color:#ff0000}4.29.4 Final scores for a paramotor championship (classes PF and PL) are calculated by normalizing the points according to the following ratios:{color}
 {color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Precision tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color}
 ...
 
{color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Navigation tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}Normalize the total score of the Economy tasks to a maximum of 3000 points.{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}&nbsp;{color} 
 
{color:#ff0000}Therefore, the winner has a maximum score of 9000 points (if they are the winner in each of the three task types){color} 
{panel} 
 
h3. Reason 
 
The score of each task must be evaluated equally in the championship competition. 
 
Section 10 states that where practicable, the tasks should ideally be balanced by 33% to each type of task: 
 
Navigation tasks 33%.
 Economy tasks 33%
 Precision tasks 33%\\
+\\
 The points awarded at AOPC2017 were heavily weighted towards precision tasks.\\
+\\
 At AOPC2017:
 ...
 
Economy task T6 T9 T13 scored up to 90 points, 23% of total points value 
 
The navigation task has a T1 T9 scored of up to 60 points, 15.3% of total points value 
 
Precision Task T2 T3 T4 T5 T8 T10 T11 T12 scored up to 240 points, 61.5% of total points value 
 
Total score 390 points were distributed as follows: Economy tasks 23%, Navigation tasks 15.3%, and Precision tasks 61.5%
 This ratio is clearly far outside of the CIMA S10 recommendation for task balance at classic competitions, and may have significantly disadvantaged pilots that have selected their equipment optimized for economy or navigation.&nbsp;
 This proposal is made out of concern that a similar imbalance might occur 2018 World Paramotor Championships, which will be hosted on the same site by the same organization team, which would contravene CIMA S10 guidelines and the spirit of fair and balanced competition that is the objective of classic style competitions.\\
+\\
 I propose to solve this problem with this amendment to S10 to be approved by the CIMA Plenary. For example, if many precision tasks are flown at a classic championship, you will normalize the total of that score to a maximum of 3000 points, so do not affect the results of other Navigation or Economy tasks.\\
+\\
 Japan delegate Ryoya Igarashi

Adaptavist Theme Builder Powered by Atlassian Confluence